Compared
Scribe vs Plaud
Plaud sells you a better microphone. Scribe sells you a defensible record of what was claimed, using the microphone you already carry.
A hardware recorder — a card or a pin — paired to a phone app and a cloud transcriber.
As of .
| Can it | Scribe | Plaud | Better |
|---|---|---|---|
| Require a second device | No. The phone in your pocket is the recorder. | Yes — the hardware is the product, and it has to be bought, charged and carried. | Scribe |
| Capture a table better than a phone can | No. Scribe uses the iPhone's microphones and nothing else. | A purpose-built recorder with a dedicated array will often out-record a phone on a table. | Them |
| Keep the audio on the phone | By default, yes. Cloud transcription is an explicit, metered opt-in, and it is the only path by which audio leaves the device. | Transcription is a cloud service; audio is uploaded to produce the transcript. | Scribe |
| Give a verdict on each claim, with evidence | Yes — extracted, scored, and marked with a verdict that names the utterance behind it. | Returns transcripts, summaries and templated notes. | Scribe |
| Play back or import recordings already stored in Plaud's cloud | No. Scribe reads nothing from another vendor's account, and there is no import. | Yes, within Plaud — they are that vendor's recordings, in that vendor's app. | Them |
| Run somewhere other than an iPhone | No. Scribe is an iPhone app. There is no wearable, no Android build, no desktop app and no web player. | See Plaud's own platform list; several of these products ship hardware or a browser app. | Them |
| Silently record a phone call | No. Scribe records the room through the phone's microphone and announces itself when it starts. | No. No consumer app on either mobile platform records calls silently — the operating systems do not expose the call audio, and the products that appear to do it are routing the call through a third party that announces itself. | Neither |
Every row about another product describes what that vendor publishes about it, checked on the date stamped above. If a row is wrong or out of date, write to hello@svrgninc.com and it will be corrected here.